Nashville Pizza Review-

Year Nine took the Pizza Committee to Music City! 23 Members joined us in the Nashville for 9th Annual Pizza Review.

Nashville’s pizza scene draws its character from a blend of Italian traditions, regional American styles, and local creativity. From large, foldable New York–style slices and crispy Chicago tavern-cut squares to wood-fired Neapolitan pies and thick, airy Sicilian sfincione, the city offers a diverse range of pizza experiences. Neighborhood slice shops, breweries, and artisan pizzerias each bring their own approach to crust, toppings, and flavor, making Nashville a city where several pizza traditions share the spotlight.

To celebrate Nashville’s musical heritage, Year Nine featured a Music City theme: “Come Dressed as Your Favorite Musician!” Our members brought their musician-inspired outfits and appetites for another memorable day of pizza and good company.

Below are the seven pizzerias we visited, ranked by the group average scores of our 23 reviewers:

  1. Dicey’s — 8.5/10

  2. Pinky Ring — 7.5/10

  3. Smith & Lentz — 7.4/10

  4. Roberta’s — 6.9/10

  5. Midnight Oil — 6.7/10

  6. St. Vito Focacceria — 6.0/10

  7. Slice House — 5.2/10

More Pictures